These picks are AI-curated from local knowledge of Anna Maria Island — real spots that locals love, no chains allowed. Updated regularly with the best the Gulf Coast has to offer.
Top Picks
The Waterline Marina Resort & Beach Club
This boutique waterfront resort sits right on Tampa Bay with stunning sunset views from every room. The intimate property feels more like a private club than a hotel, and the marina slips mean you can literally boat up to your room.
Tortuga Inn Beach Resort
A classic Old Florida beach motel that's been family-owned for decades, where the rooms open directly onto the sugar sand. The tiki bar serves the coldest beer on the island, and you're literally 50 steps from some of the best shelling spots.
Haley's Motel
This vintage 1960s motel has been lovingly restored by local owners who kept all the retro charm while adding modern amenities. The kidney-shaped pool and pink flamingo decor make it feel like stepping back into a Florida postcard.
SeaHorse Beach Resort
Tucked away on the quieter north end, this intimate resort has been welcoming families for three generations. The beachfront cottages have screened porches where you can hear the waves, and the owners still personally greet every guest.
The Inn on the Beach
This Mediterranean-style boutique inn sits right on the Gulf with only 12 rooms, making it feel like your own private beach house. The Italian owners serve fresh espresso every morning on the deck overlooking the water.
Catalina Beach Resort
A family-run property where the same local family has been hosting guests since the 1970s, known for their incredible homemade key lime pie at check-in. The Gulf-front suites have full kitchens and private balconies where dolphins swim by during breakfast.
BridgeWalk Resort
Perched right next to the historic Anna Maria City Pier, this locally-owned resort offers the best fishing access on the island. The owners are third-generation islanders who know every secret fishing spot and will gladly share their local knowledge.
The Palms of Anna Maria
This intimate beachfront property has just eight suites, each uniquely decorated by the local artist owner. The rooftop deck offers 360-degree views, and you can borrow the complimentary beach cruisers to explore the island like a local.
Coconut Inn
A charming tropical hideaway where every room opens onto lush gardens filled with coconut palms and hibiscus. The local owners serve a different homemade breakfast specialty each morning, and the honor-system tiki bar runs on island time.
Anna Maria Island Beach Resort
This family-owned resort has been passed down through three generations of islanders who treat guests like extended family. The beachfront location offers direct access to some of the island's most pristine stretches of sand, away from the crowds.