These picks come directly from our Holmes Beach city guide — updated regularly with local intelligence on the best spots, when to go, and what locals actually order.
Top Picks
The Sandbar Restaurant Tiki Bar
The rum runners flow as freely as the fishing stories at this authentic waterfront tiki bar. Locals gather here after beach days to watch boats return with the day's catch while live bands play island favorites.
Slim's Place
This dive bar institution has been serving cold beer and strong drinks to locals since the island's fishing village days. The jukebox, pool table, and no-nonsense atmosphere make it a genuine local hangout.
Tide Tables Bar
Craft cocktails with Gulf views make this upscale bar the island's most sophisticated drinking spot. Their mixologists create innovative drinks using local ingredients while sunset paints the waterfront golden.
Drift In
This laid-back beach bar captures the true island spirit with cold beer, strong drinks, and a crowd of sunburned regulars. The outdoor deck and live music make it perfect for lazy afternoon drinking sessions.
Roser Park Tavern
A true neighborhood bar where locals gather to watch games, play darts, and enjoy honest drinks at fair prices. The friendly bartenders know everyone's name and their usual order.
Duffy's Tavern
This sports bar and grill serves ice-cold beer and decent pub food in a casual atmosphere locals love. The large TVs, friendly crowd, and reasonable prices make it a reliable neighborhood spot.
Beach Bistro Bar
The island's most elegant bar serves premium cocktails and fine wines in a romantic beachfront setting. Locals celebrate anniversaries and special occasions with craft cocktails while waves lap nearby.
Ugly Grouper
Despite the name, this waterfront bar is beautiful at sunset when locals gather for happy hour specials and live music. The outdoor deck overlooking the Intracoastal Waterway offers perfect boat watching.
Anna Maria Oyster Bar Sandbar
This casual outdoor bar serves cold beer and frozen drinks steps from the beach. Locals appreciate the laid-back vibe and live music that drifts across the sand dunes.
Cortez Kitchen Bar
This historic fishing village bar maintains its authentic character while serving craft beers and creative cocktails. Locals love the maritime atmosphere and stories shared by old-time fishermen at the bar.