These picks come directly from our Longboat Key city guide — updated regularly with local intelligence on the best spots, when to go, and what locals actually order.
Top Picks
Euphemia Haye Restaurant
This eccentric Victorian mansion serves globally-inspired cuisine that changes based on the chef's creative whims, making every visit a surprise. The upstairs Haye Loft dessert bar is a local tradition, especially for the legendary chocolate soufflé that takes 25 minutes but is worth every second of the wait.
Explore this spot →
Moore's Stone Crab Restaurant
Open only during stone crab season (October-May), this no-frills spot serves the freshest claws straight from their own traps. Locals know to call ahead during peak season and always order the key lime pie to finish the meal.
Pattigeorge's Restaurant
This family-owned Greek restaurant has been serving authentic dishes since 1981, with recipes passed down through generations. The moussaka and lamb dishes transport you straight to the Mediterranean, while the casual atmosphere keeps locals coming back weekly.
Harry's Continental Kitchens
This old-school continental restaurant maintains the elegant dining traditions that built Longboat Key's reputation as a sophisticated destination. The Caesar salad is prepared tableside with theatrical flair, and the wine list focuses on classic French and Italian selections.
Explore this spot →
Anna Maria Oyster Bar Longboat Key
The grouper sandwich here has achieved legendary status among locals, who swear it's the best on the island. The bayside deck offers stunning sunset views, and the raw bar showcases the day's freshest local catches.
Explore this spot →
Dry Dock Waterfront Grill
This casual marina restaurant serves excellent seafood with a side of boat-watching, as yachts dock right outside the windows. The fish tacos are outstanding, and the conch fritters disappear quickly during happy hour.
Explore this spot →
Lazy Lobster of Longboat
Don't let the strip mall location fool you – this family-run spot serves some of the island's best seafood at prices that won't break the bank. The lobster bisque is rich and loaded with meat, while the daily catch specials showcase whatever's freshest from local waters.
Explore this spot →
Zoria
This upscale restaurant brings modern American cuisine to the island with an emphasis on seasonal ingredients and creative presentations. The chef changes the menu frequently to showcase the best local produce and seafood available.
Giuseppe's Pizzeria
New York transplants swear this thin-crust pizza rivals anything back home, with hand-tossed dough and a sauce recipe that's been in the family for decades. The small dining room gets packed during season, so locals know to order takeout for beach picnics.
Explore this spot →
Mar-Vista Dockside Restaurant
Just across the bridge on Anna Maria Island but worth the short drive, this Old Florida fish house serves grouper so fresh it was swimming that morning. The outdoor deck overlooks the marina where fishing boats unload their daily catch.
Explore this spot →