These picks are AI-curated from local knowledge of Anna Maria Island — real spots that locals love, no chains allowed. Updated regularly with the best the Gulf Coast has to offer.
Top Picks
The Sandbar Restaurant
This waterfront gem sits right on the bay with boats pulling up to the dock while you're eating stone crab claws. The sunset views are legendary, and locals know to arrive early for their famous grouper sandwich and a cold beer on the deck.
Bean Point Beach
The island's best-kept secret sits at the very northern tip where Tampa Bay meets the Gulf of Mexico. Most tourists never make it this far, so you'll often have this pristine stretch of sand and amazing views all to yourself.
Historic Green Village
This charming collection of restored 1920s cottages houses local artisans, vintage shops, and the island's quirkiest finds. The old-timers remember when these were actual homes, and now each cottage tells its own story through unique local businesses.
Cortez Fishing Village
Step back in time at this working fishing village that's been operating since the 1880s. Watch mullet fishermen mend their nets the same way their grandfathers did, and grab fresh grouper straight off the boats at the fish market.
Coquina Beach
While tourists flock to other beaches, locals love this southern stretch for its wide expanse and the famous Coquina Baywalk. The fishing pier extends into the Gulf, and the nature trail through the dunes is perfect for spotting shore birds.
Anna Maria Island Historical Society Museum
Housed in the old city jail and ice house, this tiny museum tells the real story of island life before the bridges brought the crowds. The volunteer docents are longtime residents who share stories you won't find in any guidebook.
Rod & Reel Pier
This 1947 wooden fishing pier stretches 200 feet into Tampa Bay and remains the island's most iconic landmark. Early morning brings serious anglers casting for snook and redfish, while sunset draws couples and photographers.
Bayfront Park
This hidden bayside park offers some of the island's most spectacular sunset views without the crowds. Locals bring their dogs here for evening walks and watch manatees surface in the calm waters near the small fishing dock.
The City Pier
Anna Maria's historic city pier has been rebuilt several times after hurricanes, but locals always gather here for fishing, pelican watching, and catching the sunrise over Tampa Bay. The small bait shop at the base has been run by the same family for decades.
Greer Island
This tiny mangrove island is only accessible by kayak or small boat, making it a local favorite for escaping the crowds entirely. The shallow waters around it are perfect for spotting rays, and the island itself is a haven for nesting birds.